Skip to Main Content

InfoSkills for Social and Behavioral Sciences

InfoSkills @ TiU

Google Scholar vs. library databases

Google Scholar Library databases
+ Easy to use because it has a simple, clean interface and requires no special search skills. Not so easy to use because they require knowledge of advanced search techniques.
+ Helpful for beginners searching for sources on an unfamiliar topic because it searches broadly and ranks results by citations, making it easier to find important research. Less helpful for beginners searching for a new topic due to complex search rules and limited coverage, making it harder to quickly find relevant research.
Basic search functionality. Google Scholar often returns a massive number of results, but with few effective filtering options, resulting in limited control over your searches. + Extensive search functionality. Databases return a manageable number of results for similar searches. Their many advanced filter options offer maximum control over your searches.
Compiled by a web crawler that searches content available on the surface web – that is, publicly accessible websites and sources. + Compiled by information professionals who carefully select and organize high-quality content from both the surface web and the deep web.
+ Effective for finding grey literature. Library databases often focus on traditionally published materials, not grey literature.
No helpful details about the publications (e.g., subject-related terms such as subjects, descriptors or keywords) are provided. + Additional details are provided for each publication (e.g., database-specific terms such as subjects, descriptors, or keywords, which are assigned by subject experts).
Google Scholar's crawlers can be fooled, resulting in unreliable materials being indexed (e.g., articles from predatory journals). + Only credible materials are indexed, as subject experts review the content who are not easily misled.

Creative Commons License This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License by Tilburg University.